Imagine this situation. You are supposed to send an email to your manager. You write draft after draft, and each one isn’t good enough.
It needs to be clear and brief without offending, yet you’ve convinced yourself the email will do just that, so you leave it in your draft folder. After that, you push it out of your mind and never look at that email again.
Many Gen Z employees have experienced this. But it’s not a reflection on the individual; rather, it is a systems issue. Technology has fundamentally changed communication, so we no longer have to talk to people face-to-face.
Now imagine growing up with this technology. Gen Z have grown up looking at screens and messaging their friends online; many of their face-to-face meetings were at school. Then Covid-19 disrupted those interactions, and people could only talk to each other through their devices. When they were not communicating, they were doomscrolling on social media, exposed to cancel culture and cyberbullying.
Modern technologies have moulded Gen Z’s development in ways we are just beginning to understand, and perhaps the first step is to examine the causes one by one.
Growth of digital communication rewired the skillset
70% of 18-34-year-olds would rather use text messaging than phone calls. You can see the appeal when you think about it. Verbal communication requires thinking on the spot, while text messaging doesn’t. You can edit before sending, delay responses, and avoid immediate emotional reactions – it is planned communication.
Compared with phone calls or face-to-face communication, text messages offer time and comfortable emotional distance. The only disadvantage is that the lack of real, unstructured communication leaves Gen Z unsure what to do in face-to-face encounters.
The rise of conflict avoidance
It’s human nature to avoid conflict, but avoidance is impossible on social media. Cancel culture has made us more cautious about what we say because almost anything can be seen as offensive or out of touch.
While social skills require a degree of self-censorship, Gen Z feel the need to be likeable and correct twenty-four-seven. Even the tiniest slip or misunderstanding can have damaging consequences in virtual life and, possibly, in real life. It’s no wonder, then, that young people avoid conflict. If everyone is waiting for you to cancel yourself, what’s the point in having difficult conversations?
Emotional intelligence vs execution gap
Of all the generations, Gen Z are the most outspoken about mental health. But some still find transparent conversations uncomfortable.
A UNICEF study found that 4 in 10 of Gen Z globally are reluctant to discuss mental health in schools and workplaces. This suggests that some young people don’t feel safe sharing their own mental health struggles in these formal environments. In addition, only half of the sample knew where to find resources to support their mental health. As a consequence, Gen Z may lack the tools to manage difficult conversations, and their tendency to avoid them compounds the issue.
Ghosting as a socially accepted exit
We all know you shouldn’t ghost someone. It is discourteous and wastes the other person’s time, yet it is a socially acceptable exit.
84% of Gen Z and Millennials have been ghosted, and 77% of Gen Z admit to ghosting someone – nearly two-thirds did it to avoid having uncomfortable conversations.
While ghosting is more common in online dating and social media, we can see a pattern of behaviour that can spill over into the workplace. Gen Z and Millennials would rather leave a conversation entirely than face a difficult conversation. In this sense, it is their form of conflict resolution.
Fewer real-life reps growing up.
Reading all of this, one might think that Gen Z were rude, but that’s not true. The sharper point is that they haven’t had enough practice with face-to-face communication. When they were growing up, they talked to their friends in the schoolyard, where teachers mediated some of their conflicts. It was structured, and face-to-face meetings were unavoidable. These things change as we join the workforce: we focus on our work and must settle conflicts ourselves. It is a completely different environment, which might explain why 85% of Gen Z say they spend too much time online.
Values clash: kindness or honesty?
Gen Z are working alongside Millennials, Generation X and Baby Boomers. Each of them comes with different values.
The most vocal are probably Gen Z and Millennials. A 2024 study found that 61% of Gen Z and Millennial employees want their companies to take a stand on issues and world events; however, one-third of the wider employee sample feel unsafe having difficult conversations with their managers.
There are two explanations:
Firstly, Gen Z are committed to inclusivity, respect and emotional safety, but they don’t know how to have uncomfortable conversations without violating these values.
Secondly, they are afraid of making mistakes this early in their careers.
This puts managers in an awkward position. How can they get young people to be open? How can they give constructive criticism without causing harm For anyone managing across generations, these differences can present a challenge.
Workplace amplifier
We’ve already discussed the pressure and cultural adjustments Gen Z face in the workplace, but let’s explore how these affect them…
A survey described nearly 49% of Gen Z workers as definitely or probably relying more on ChatGPT than managers to answer questions. One explanation for this is that Gen Z are afraid of making mistakes that could jeopardise their careers, and they use ChatGPT because they fear human judgement. But, of course, this makes their communication problems worse.
Overreliance on ChatGPT can make you doubt your own judgement and encourage overthinking. From this, we can infer that Gen Z can be insecure in their judgements, especially in formal environments.
Reframe: this is an adaptation, not a deficit
Gen Z values stability, wellbeing, and sustainable growth over rapid advancement. This makes sense given the digital environments they grew up in and the transition from structured to unstructured social and work environments.
So, how can managers lighten their burdens?
Teach Gen Z frameworks for honest conversations, including giving and receiving feedback.
Create low-risk practice environments.
Help Gen Z see mistakes as learning opportunities rather than career-breakers.
Every generation struggles with what they didn’t practice. Managers: train Gen Z to communicate effectively… and Gen Z: have messy, imperfect face-to-face conversations.
Want to help your Gen Z employees feel more confident having difficult conversations at work? Get in touch to discuss practical ways we can support your team.